第17回次世代医療教育研究会@自治医科大学 開催日：2017/12/09-10 公開用スライド Meta-analysis入門「めたあなりしすっ！」

1. ) ( () ( K
B71 ( [w s
_ ac]
K PN P LK K I LC BP K IT
EPPM SSS PE NLB KBP ) ( ()( BKD M C U M
12017/12/10 © 2017 TAKAORI L. HIROE; DEPT. OF BIOSTATISTICS, KYOTO UNIVERSITY SCHOOL OF PUBLIC HEALTH
s s
TLPL K BN PT 1N PB ELLI LC B KB
z t jrk
/BM NP BKP LC - L P P P .BKPBN CLN B I 0 P LK
uo ifdhilp v y u dmneg
: H KLN 2 NLB# . 0 P E NLB P K GM
DN : ou=Verified Email: t-hiroe@umin.ac.jp, email=t-
hiroe@umin.ac.jp,
0.9.2342.19200300.100.1.1=7F0000010000015D5DB
3B8730000D390
日付 : 2017.12.11 07:04:48 +09'00'
Adobe Acrobat バージョン : 11.0.23

2. 2017/12/10 © 2017 TAKAORI L. HIROE; DEPT. OF BIOSTATISTICS, KYOTO UNIVERSITY SCHOOL OF PUBLIC HEALTH 2
…

3. 2017/12/10 © 2017 TAKAORI L. HIROE; DEPT. OF BIOSTATISTICS, KYOTO UNIVERSITY SCHOOL OF PUBLIC HEALTH 3

4. 2017/12/10 © 2017 TAKAORI L. HIROE; DEPT. OF BIOSTATISTICS, KYOTO UNIVERSITY SCHOOL OF PUBLIC HEALTH 4
#
◦ 1 7 17:00 19:00
◦ https://lounge.dmm.com/detail/657/

5. 32- .
O
• 2 . -41 1
• 12 - 2
• a P
M
• F
• F
2017/12/10 © 2017 TAKAORI L. HIROE; DEPT. OF BIOSTATISTICS, KYOTO UNIVERSITY SCHOOL OF PUBLIC HEALTH 5

6. 32- .
O
• 2 . -41 1
• 12 - 2
• a P
M
• F
• F
2017/12/10 © 2017 TAKAORI L. HIROE; DEPT. OF BIOSTATISTICS, KYOTO UNIVERSITY SCHOOL OF PUBLIC HEALTH 6

7. • s li
• C
• n
• R
• M M - T
•
• a
• - e li t
2017/12/10 © 2017 TAKAORI L. HIROE; DEPT. OF BIOSTATISTICS, KYOTO UNIVERSITY SCHOOL OF PUBLIC HEALTH 7

8. 2017/12/10 © 2017 TAKAORI L. HIROE; DEPT. OF BIOSTATISTICS, KYOTO UNIVERSITY SCHOOL OF PUBLIC HEALTH 8

9. 21 -
• 1 - 3 4
• . 1 .1
P F
•
• M O
2017/12/10 © 2017 TAKAORI L. HIROE; DEPT. OF BIOSTATISTICS, KYOTO UNIVERSITY SCHOOL OF PUBLIC HEALTH 9

10. •
• s
• a y -
• M i
• s - -
• ln t
• -ln
• e - ln
• -ln
2017/12/10 © 2017 TAKAORI L. HIROE; DEPT. OF BIOSTATISTICS, KYOTO UNIVERSITY SCHOOL OF PUBLIC HEALTH 10

11. 4 0
•P 3 5
• 8 7 A
•
!"#"$!%#%
&"$&%
• P1. . Q
. Q
• P . . Q B
. Q B
2017/12/10 © 2017 TAKAORI L. HIROE; DEPT. OF BIOSTATISTICS, KYOTO UNIVERSITY SCHOOL OF PUBLIC HEALTH 11

12. 1
. -
2. #$%&ℎ( =
*
4
3 M
M
2017/12/10 © 2017 TAKAORI L. HIROE; DEPT. OF BIOSTATISTICS, KYOTO UNIVERSITY SCHOOL OF PUBLIC HEALTH 12

13. T
• S
• I O C
• Y L
•PE M FN M U
2017/12/10 © 2017 TAKAORI L. HIROE; DEPT. OF BIOSTATISTICS, KYOTO UNIVERSITY SCHOOL OF PUBLIC HEALTH 13

14. •
•
• M -
142017/12/10 © 2017 TAKAORI L. HIROE; DEPT. OF BIOSTATISTICS, KYOTO UNIVERSITY SCHOOL OF PUBLIC HEALTH

15. •
• F
•P
• P
•
•
•
2017/12/10 © 2017 TAKAORI L. HIROE; DEPT. OF BIOSTATISTICS, KYOTO UNIVERSITY SCHOOL OF PUBLIC HEALTH 15

16. ) e
• e i gl aF W
E SR e
• ) e m
• F
• bm (
( SR
2017/12/10 © 2017 TAKAORI L. HIROE; DEPT. OF BIOSTATISTICS, KYOTO UNIVERSITY SCHOOL OF PUBLIC HEALTH 16

17. 0
• . = n 4 E
•W 4 2 1 = 30
• = =4 FE
• n n 0
• α= 1 − (1 − $)&
• =5
• =5
• =5
• 3R 4 E
2017/12/10 © 2017 TAKAORI L. HIROE; DEPT. OF BIOSTATISTICS, KYOTO UNIVERSITY SCHOOL OF PUBLIC HEALTH 17

18. •
•
•
•
•
•
2017/12/10 © 2017 TAKAORI L. HIROE; DEPT. OF BIOSTATISTICS, KYOTO UNIVERSITY SCHOOL OF PUBLIC HEALTH 18

19. 2017/12/10 © 2017 TAKAORI L. HIROE; DEPT. OF BIOSTATISTICS, KYOTO UNIVERSITY SCHOOL OF PUBLIC HEALTH 19
JAMA. 2014; 312: 171-179.

20. A
•pt hl< r c P C
s F M F A
• >pthl J A
• 5 1 5 MQ J M
•n <P C s
• 502 . 1 < o
• !"
1 < !"
% s A o
• pt a Fe
2017/12/10 © 2017 TAKAORI L. HIROE; DEPT. OF BIOSTATISTICS, KYOTO UNIVERSITY SCHOOL OF PUBLIC HEALTH 20

21. 2017/12/10 © 2017 TAKAORI L. HIROE; DEPT. OF BIOSTATISTICS, KYOTO UNIVERSITY SCHOOL OF PUBLIC HEALTH 21

22. g o
•
• r s el M
• r s al p y Si
• Sn
• u M g
elSeo t
• b o
•
2017/12/10 © 2017 TAKAORI L. HIROE; DEPT. OF BIOSTATISTICS, KYOTO UNIVERSITY SCHOOL OF PUBLIC HEALTH 22

23. 2017/12/10 © 2017 TAKAORI L. HIROE; DEPT. OF BIOSTATISTICS, KYOTO UNIVERSITY SCHOOL OF PUBLIC HEALTH 23
Prospective Meta-Analysis

24. 2017/12/10 © 2017 TAKAORI L. HIROE; DEPT. OF BIOSTATISTICS, KYOTO UNIVERSITY SCHOOL OF PUBLIC HEALTH 24

25. •
•
•
•
2017/12/10 © 2017 TAKAORI L. HIROE; DEPT. OF BIOSTATISTICS, KYOTO UNIVERSITY SCHOOL OF PUBLIC HEALTH 25

26. 32- .
O
• 2 . -41 1
• 12 - 2
• a P
M
• F
• F
2017/12/10 © 2017 TAKAORI L. HIROE; DEPT. OF BIOSTATISTICS, KYOTO UNIVERSITY SCHOOL OF PUBLIC HEALTH 26

27. 2017/12/10 © 2017 TAKAORI L. HIROE; DEPT. OF BIOSTATISTICS, KYOTO UNIVERSITY SCHOOL OF PUBLIC HEALTH 27
DL: http://community.cochrane.org/tools/review-production-tools/revman-5

28. 1 1 .7.21
•) 0 .7 ) 7
• ) 0 .7 / . M Le
• htw lu
• i n o W e e
• y 1/ a W e
• 1 . .7. b
• ro m 1 2 1 . a e c
• vs
• a Leb eC
• R g W e
2017/12/10 © 2017 TAKAORI L. HIROE; DEPT. OF BIOSTATISTICS, KYOTO UNIVERSITY SCHOOL OF PUBLIC HEALTH 28

29. 2017/12/10 © 2017 TAKAORI L. HIROE; DEPT. OF BIOSTATISTICS, KYOTO UNIVERSITY SCHOOL OF PUBLIC HEALTH 29

30. 2017/12/10 © 2017 TAKAORI L. HIROE; DEPT. OF BIOSTATISTICS, KYOTO UNIVERSITY SCHOOL OF PUBLIC HEALTH 30

31. 2017/12/10 © 2017 TAKAORI L. HIROE; DEPT. OF BIOSTATISTICS, KYOTO UNIVERSITY SCHOOL OF PUBLIC HEALTH 31

32. 2017/12/10 © 2017 TAKAORI L. HIROE; DEPT. OF BIOSTATISTICS, KYOTO UNIVERSITY SCHOOL OF PUBLIC HEALTH 32

33. 2017/12/10 © 2017 TAKAORI L. HIROE; DEPT. OF BIOSTATISTICS, KYOTO UNIVERSITY SCHOOL OF PUBLIC HEALTH 33

34. 2017/12/10 © 2017 TAKAORI L. HIROE; DEPT. OF BIOSTATISTICS, KYOTO UNIVERSITY SCHOOL OF PUBLIC HEALTH 34
Tables
→ Characteristics of studies
Data and Analysis
→ Add Comparison

35. 2017/12/10 © 2017 TAKAORI L. HIROE; DEPT. OF BIOSTATISTICS, KYOTO UNIVERSITY SCHOOL OF PUBLIC HEALTH 35
Add Study
OK

36. 2017/12/10 © 2017 TAKAORI L. HIROE; DEPT. OF BIOSTATISTICS, KYOTO UNIVERSITY SCHOOL OF PUBLIC HEALTH 36

37. 2017/12/10 © 2017 TAKAORI L. HIROE; DEPT. OF BIOSTATISTICS, KYOTO UNIVERSITY SCHOOL OF PUBLIC HEALTH 37

38. 2017/12/10 © 2017 TAKAORI L. HIROE; DEPT. OF BIOSTATISTICS, KYOTO UNIVERSITY SCHOOL OF PUBLIC HEALTH 38

39. 2017/12/10 © 2017 TAKAORI L. HIROE; DEPT. OF BIOSTATISTICS, KYOTO UNIVERSITY SCHOOL OF PUBLIC HEALTH 39

40. 2017/12/10 © 2017 TAKAORI L. HIROE; DEPT. OF BIOSTATISTICS, KYOTO UNIVERSITY SCHOOL OF PUBLIC HEALTH 40

41. 2017/12/10 © 2017 TAKAORI L. HIROE; DEPT. OF BIOSTATISTICS, KYOTO UNIVERSITY SCHOOL OF PUBLIC HEALTH 41

42. 2017/12/10 © 2017 TAKAORI L. HIROE; DEPT. OF BIOSTATISTICS, KYOTO UNIVERSITY SCHOOL OF PUBLIC HEALTH 42

43. 2017/12/10 © 2017 TAKAORI L. HIROE; DEPT. OF BIOSTATISTICS, KYOTO UNIVERSITY SCHOOL OF PUBLIC HEALTH 43

44. 2017/12/10 © 2017 TAKAORI L. HIROE; DEPT. OF BIOSTATISTICS, KYOTO UNIVERSITY SCHOOL OF PUBLIC HEALTH 44

45. 2017/12/10 © 2017 TAKAORI L. HIROE; DEPT. OF BIOSTATISTICS, KYOTO UNIVERSITY SCHOOL OF PUBLIC HEALTH 45

46. 2017/12/10 © 2017 TAKAORI L. HIROE; DEPT. OF BIOSTATISTICS, KYOTO UNIVERSITY SCHOOL OF PUBLIC HEALTH 46

47. 2017/12/10 © 2017 TAKAORI L. HIROE; DEPT. OF BIOSTATISTICS, KYOTO UNIVERSITY SCHOOL OF PUBLIC HEALTH 47

48. 2017/12/10 © 2017 TAKAORI L. HIROE; DEPT. OF BIOSTATISTICS, KYOTO UNIVERSITY SCHOOL OF PUBLIC HEALTH 48

49. 2017/12/10 © 2017 TAKAORI L. HIROE; DEPT. OF BIOSTATISTICS, KYOTO UNIVERSITY SCHOOL OF PUBLIC HEALTH 49

50. /
2017/12/10 © 2017 TAKAORI L. HIROE; DEPT. OF BIOSTATISTICS, KYOTO UNIVERSITY SCHOOL OF PUBLIC HEALTH 50

51. 2017/12/10 © 2017 TAKAORI L. HIROE; DEPT. OF BIOSTATISTICS, KYOTO UNIVERSITY SCHOOL OF PUBLIC HEALTH 51

52. 2017/12/10 © 2017 TAKAORI L. HIROE; DEPT. OF BIOSTATISTICS, KYOTO UNIVERSITY SCHOOL OF PUBLIC HEALTH 52

53. 2017/12/10 © 2017 TAKAORI L. HIROE; DEPT. OF BIOSTATISTICS, KYOTO UNIVERSITY SCHOOL OF PUBLIC HEALTH 53
SE (Publication bias ?)

54. 2017/12/10 © 2017 TAKAORI L. HIROE; DEPT. OF BIOSTATISTICS, KYOTO UNIVERSITY SCHOOL OF PUBLIC HEALTH 54

55. 32- .
O
• 2 . -41 1
• 12 - 2
• a P
M
• F
• F
2017/12/10 © 2017 TAKAORI L. HIROE; DEPT. OF BIOSTATISTICS, KYOTO UNIVERSITY SCHOOL OF PUBLIC HEALTH 55

56. •
• M
• l M
• M
•
• s ty in M M
• a M
• !"
in e
•
M -
2017/12/10 © 2017 TAKAORI L. HIROE; DEPT. OF BIOSTATISTICS, KYOTO UNIVERSITY SCHOOL OF PUBLIC HEALTH 56